Ambient scribes and inbox drafts

Ambient scribes draft visit notes from the clinician-patient conversation, and inbox tools draft replies to patients' portal messages, for clinicians to review.

8 tools · Reviewed · How we grade

A clipboard with a note of short ruled lines lying beside a desk microphone.
Category overviewHide category overview

Ambient scribes listen to the visit and draft the note. Columbia Nursing, summarizing its researchers' commentary, said scribes are often classified as administrative tools rather than medical devices, allowing them to bypass FDA regulation. A Swedish health technology assessment found four randomized trials, all in the U.S., with 23 to 238 physicians each, and no data on total documentation time including editing, or on accuracy. Kaiser Permanente researchers estimated that scribes saved nearly 16,000 hours of documentation time over more than 2.5 million uses. In a MedStar Health simulation, 31 of 44 draft notes contained errors.

Inbox tools draft replies to messages from patients, which rose to 157% of the prepandemic average for U.S. ambulatory clinicians during the pandemic. Of 23 studies in a 2025 systematic review of AI-drafted replies, 16 were simulations; all seven in live use tested GPT-4 tools built into Epic. In a Mass General Brigham simulation, 7.1% of GPT-4 drafts could pose a risk to the patient if sent unedited, and 0.6% a risk of death.

Read as an explainer

Grade ARandomized evidence of benefit

Abridge

Abridge AI

Ambient AI scribe that listens to clinician-patient visits and drafts a structured note for the clinician to review.

Read the full review with Pro

The grade is free. The evidence behind it, the prices and every source are for members.

Founding Pro: $149 a year, locked while you stay. Until Dec. 31. Regular price $249 a year.

Compare plans

Already a member? Sign in

Grade BEvidence from clinical use

Ambience

Ambience Healthcare

Ambient AI scribe that drafts encounter notes in the electronic health record from recorded clinician-patient conversations for clinician review.

Details for members

Grade DLittle or no independent evidence

Commure Ambient

Commure

Ambient AI documentation tool that records clinician-patient encounters and drafts clinical notes for clinicians to review and sign.

Details for members

Grade BEvidence from clinical use

Epic In Basket draft replies

Epic Systems · Augmented response technology (ART); part of Epic Art

Generative AI in Epic's In Basket that drafts replies to patient portal messages for clinicians to edit.

Details for members

Grade BEvidence from clinical use

Heidi Health

Heidi; Heidi AI

Ambient AI scribe from an Australian company that drafts notes, discharge summaries and letters from recorded consultations for clinician review.

Details for members

Grade BEvidence from clinical use

Microsoft Dragon Copilot

Microsoft · Formerly DAX Copilot (Dragon Ambient eXperience)

Microsoft's ambient AI scribe and dictation assistant, which drafts notes from recorded clinician-patient conversations.

Details for members

Grade ARandomized evidence of benefit

Nabla

Formerly Nabla Copilot

Ambient AI assistant that captures the clinician-patient conversation and generates a structured clinical note.

Details for members

Grade DLittle or no independent evidence

Suki Assistant

Suki AI · Suki

AI assistant and ambient scribe that drafts structured clinical notes from recorded encounters inside the electronic health record.

Details for members

Reviews of the published evidence, not medical advice or an endorsement of any product.

Ask Physician in the Loop

0 / 500

Answers come only from Physician in the Loop's published reviews, law map, explainers and posts, with links. They can be wrong. They are not medical or legal advice. Do not enter patient information.

More about the Ask box